Why Oh Why Podcast

Seattle blasted their way through Spring Training and the World Baseball Classic which should only raise expectations for the inevitable fall into disappointment! Tyler and Tyler break down all the reasons for optimism, reasons for disappointment and play a rousing round of Over/Under. Go Mariners!

Another offseason, another near-total turnover of the Seattle Mariners roster. Jerry Dipoto has been busy filling Tyler and Tyler with worry about how things are going to pan out. We break down all the moves this winter and make very different analogies, one of which might be better than the other.

Episode 11: Darrell Johnson, The OG of Disappointment by Why Oh Why Podcast

Tyler and Tyler rehash the highs and lows of the first half of the 2016 season and predict just how deeply the Mariners will hurt them this fall.

Episode 9: The Dad Interview by Why Oh Why Podcast

How do you pull off the worst trade in baseball history? Trade away 3 All Stars in a 5-for-1 deal that nets you a singular surly pitcher who can't stay healthy. Tyler and Tyler break down the Great Seattle Heist that was the Erik Bedard trade!

Tyler and Tyler take a break from getting depressed about baseball to talk about the neurotic machismo that abounds on the Bachelorette.

The 2001 regular season remains the high-water mark for the Seattle Mariner franchise and any franchise in baseball history. Then the entire team went missing for the ALCS against the Yankees. Guess which part Tyler and Tyler obsess over!

Join hosts Tyler and Tyler as they subject themselves to reliving the 2013 season, which was described by expert disappointment Howard Lincoln as "the most disappointing season" he had been a part of. Drink in the sadness!

A catcher so nice, they signed him twice! Tyler and Tyler break down the puzzling acquisition and re-acquisition of the worst catcher in Seattle Mariners history, Miguel Olivo.

What happens when the Seattle Mariners throw an obscene amount of money at a mediocre pitcher to fix their rotation issues? Nothing good! Revisit the Bavasi-esque catastrophe that was Carlos Silva as Tyler and Tyler break down everything that went wrong with this baffling free agency blunder.

Join Tyler and Tyler as they relive the rapid descent of Chone Figgins and the single moment that apparently ruined his life.

Tyler and Tyler relive the nightmare that was Bobby Ayala and the Seattle Mariners bullpen of the 1990s.

The inaugural episode of the Why Oh Why Podcast! In it, Tyler and Tyler will talk about those experiences that have shaped them as Seattle Mariners fans and what keeps them coming back year after disappointing year.