P.S. You're Wrong: A Pop Culture Podcast-logo

P.S. You're Wrong: A Pop Culture Podcast

Television >

More Information


United States




Five Feet Apart & Captive State (Episode 35)

It’s a double feature! Starting with the doomed YA romance, Five Feet Apart, Shelby and Matt talk about where this movie came from and what it accomplishes and why exactly Shelby was weeping at the end. But things get heated when they turn to the alien thriller Captive State (19:25). Listen to them duke it out over extraterrestrial motivations and ensemble casts. Spoilers abound (but that just makes this conversation more fun).


Pop Culture Roundup #2

Shelby and Matt jump right in with their take on the college admissions scam (3:43) before going in on James Gunn (14:27), the new Double Shot of Love (18:04), and Britney Spears’ feminist jukebox musical (19:54). Finally, JK Rowling gets explicit about Dumbledore’s sex life (23:47) and Shane Dawson never had sex with a cat (28:08). For Love it or Hate it (30:51), Matt discovers RuPaul’s Drag Race and Shelby is thrilled for a third season of Queer Eye.


Captain Marvel (Episode 34)

This episode is all about Captain Marvel. From the MCU trolls to the box office numbers and everything in between, Shelby and Matt talk about what works, what doesn’t, and which of them actually liked the movie. Spoiler alert starting at 24:12 and lightning round questions at 40:44.


Pop Culture Roundup #1

Shelby and Matt introduce a new format with their pop culture roundup coming to you separately. They talk about The Bachelor (6:22), Adnan Syed’s case (12:48), The Hills diversity problem (16:09), trouble in J-Lo and A-Rod’s newly minted paradise (18:16) and whether or not Idris Elba is making the right career choices (21:00). For Love it or Hate it, Shelby can’t stop listening to “Love You Like That” by Dagny and Matt talks up Climax, the horror/dance mashup of his dreams.


Survivor: Edge of Extinction (Episode 33)

There’s an update on the Khloe Kardashian drama (3:56) and Pete Davidson’s BDE (9:49). Then we talk about billionaire Kylie Jenner (12:31), Luke Perry (13:33) and Steven Spielberg’s fight against Netflix (16:48). Matt’s dreams come true when they start talking Survivor (21:57). From 38 seasons of strategy to what the heck an idol is, Matt is answering all the questions as they unpack the Edge of Extinction. For Love It or Hate it (1:09:27), Shelby talks about Fighting with my Family and Matt...


The 91st Academy Awards (Episode 32)

Shelby unpacks the latest in Taylor Swift fan theories (5:25). Matt catches us up on the Jussie Smollet case (12:48). Shelby revels in the latest Kardashian scandal (18:38). And Matt spills the beans on the Oscar gift bags (27:18). Then it’s time to recap the 91st Academy Awards, from all the things that worked and all the things that didn’t. Plus it’s a game of Would It Have Worked where we revisit all the things that could have been and the winner of our giveaway. For Love It or Hate It...


2018 Film Rankings (Episode 31 - Special Edition)

Buckle up, this one’s a doozy. Shelby and Matt rank every movie they saw in 2018 from worst to best. THe catch: it’s the average of both. Who’s taste will come out on top? To skip around in the bloodbath here are the timestamps for our top 113 (6:15), 100 (20:04), 75 (47:48), 50 (1:10:04), 25 (1:37:35), and 10 (1:53:42).


The Lego Movie 2 - The Second Part (Episode 30)

Dina Lohan might be being catfished (5:00). Ryan Murphy got Matt’s hopes up about Scream Queens (8:36). Justin Bieber and Hailey Baldwin are working hard on their marriage (13:01). And celebrities are over FckJerry (20:14). But everything is awesome when they start talking about *The Lego Movie 2: The Second Part (27:05) and whether or not this sequel can stack up to the original. For Love it or Hate It, Shelby does a deep dive into Ariana Grande’s new album, Thank U Next (1:06:34) and Matt...


Serenity (Episode 29)

Shelby and Matt discuss Ariana Grande’s love of Japanese BBQ (3:48), Adam Levine’s half-hearted Halftime show (7:53), Liam Neeson (16:00), and the New Yorker story on Dan Mallory (20:34). Then it’s time to get into Serenity (25:45), the Matthew McConaughey and Anne Hathaway thriller no one’s seeing but everyone’s talking about. Spoiler warning at 37:22. For Love It or Hate It (57:54) it’s all about Netflix as Matt rails on The Ballad of Buster Scruggs and Shelby recommends Abducted in Plain...


Glass (Episode 28)

Matt runs wild with news of a Princess Diaries sequel (4:58) while Shelby dreams up some drama between Kim Kardashian and Taylor Swift (8:50). Rent Live reminds us all to always have a backup plan (11:21) while Pete Davidson milks the Ariana breakup for some comedy material (13:56). But Shelby and Matt are split on how they feel about the Feature Presentation: Glass (16:01). Is the M. N. Shyamalan trilogy finale half full or half empty? SPOILERS ABOUND (24:51). For Love It or Hate It...


2019 Oscar Nominees (Episode 27)

It’s bad news as Shelby and Matt catch up on Chris Brown (1:59), Bryan Singer (5:29), and the Cats movie that is definitely happening (7:34). But at least there’s Ariana Grande’s newest album to look forward to (9:54). And then for the feature presentation (12:23) they’re talking about all the nominations for the 91st Annual Academy awards – both what was nominated and what they wish had made the cut. For Love It or Hate It (1:02:24) Shelby gives Riverdale a chance and Matt reviews Fyre on...


2019 Film Preview (Episode 26)

Shelby and Matt talk about Big Brother Celebrity (4:02), the most liked egg on Instagram (7:22), Game of Thrones (10:18), and Lifetime’s Surviving R. Kelly (12:18). Then they go through the movie releases of 2019 (1:20:56) as they attempt to guess their favorites and the critic darlings…based on nothing but hot takes. For Love it or Hate It (1:27:57), Matt sings praises to Support the Girls and Shelby is surprised to like Netflix’s You.


The 76th Golden Globes (Episode 25)

Shelby and Matt discuss the Bird Box Challenge (3:23), Kendall Jenner’s big news (7:15), and the latest WTF musing from JK Rowling (12:27). Then it’s time to talk all about the Golden Globes (18:17) and what it means for the Oscar race. For Love it or Hate It (1:11:42), Matt goes off on Vice and Shelby is all in on If Beale Street Could Talk.


Mary Poppins Returns & A Holiday Movie Roundup (Episode 24)

It’s a new year and all new drama. Kim and Kanye are expecting(5:57). NYE was a letdown (8:35). Tiffany Haddish had an off day (12:34). Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth sealed the deal (15:46). And Louis CK does it again (17:26). Then Shelby and Matt catch you up on all the movies they saw over break (23:17) with The Old Man and the Gun, Aquaman, The Grinch, Birdbox, The Mule, and Bandersnatch before bringing it home with Mary Poppins Returns (48:08). For Love It or Hate it (1:13:03), Matt...


Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (Episode 23)

Matt hyped up Stranger Things (2:38), Shelby has to mention Kanye and Ariana Grande (5:00). They talk about Beyoncé performing at weddings (10:43), whether or not Nicki Minaj should deal with public inquiries about her boyfriend (15:27) and how the Oscars are shaping up after the SAG nominations (21:32). For the feature presentation, it’s a movie Shelby’s been gunning for and one Matthew meant to avoid: it’s time to talk about Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (28:00). For Love It or Hate It...


Green Book, Grammys & Golden Globes (Episode 22)

Matt brings up Kevin Hart and the search for the perfect Oscar host (3:37) while Shelby mentions Katy Perry’s latest public display of awkwardness (14:12). Then it’s time to talk Grammy nominations (18:56) and an in-depth Golden Globes discussion (30:36) before jumping into the surprise critical contender, Green Book (53:54). They talk about the purpose of the film, what makes it so palatable, and if it could/should stand a chance in the Oscar race. For Love It or Hate It (1:15:56), Shelby...


Creed II w/ Hannah Ward (Episode 21)

This week features a special guest and friend, Hannah Ward, bringing her expertise to the Creed discussion. But first it’s all about Nick Jonas and Priyanka Chopra’s sponcon wedding (3:52), Pete Davidson’s plea for respect, Ariana Grande’s Thank U, Next video (7:37), and Gigi Hadid’s biggest fear (16:45). Then it’s time for the action with Creed II (23:32). Shelby and Matt pick Hannah’s brain about being an extra and just how close she got to Michael B. Jordan as they discuss the film and...


Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald (Episode 20)

Shelby and Matt catch you up on all the celebrity profiles of the week with Amanda Bynes (5:37), Lena Dunham (8:10), and Shawn Mendes (11:36) and then come back to The Lion King trailer (16:12) . Then it’s on to the Feature Presentation (20:49) where they rear their Potterheads with talk of JK Rowling, Fantastic Beasts, and the many crimes of Crimes of Grindelwald. Major spoilers start at 50:49. For Love it Or Hate It (1:06:47) Shelby stands up for Widows and Matt is taken aback by Instant...


P.S. You're Wrong About: Anne Hathaway (Episode 19 - Birthday Special)

In this special episode honoring Matt’s birthday, Shelby and Matt take a break from their usual format to visit the highs and lows of a specific pop culture icon. For this inaugural Birthday Special, they’re talking all things Anne Hathaway. First, they get things started with a few stories about their celebrity encounters (5:53), including run ins with Taylor Swift and Kevin Spacey. Once things move to Anne Hathaway (19:28), they discuss the highs, the lows — and the Hathahaters before...


Bohemian Rhapsody (Episode 18)

Shelby talks about Ariana Grande’s latest hit, Thank U Next (1:12) before Matt brings up Alec Baldwin’s most Alec Baldwin arrest (10:18). Then it’s Rebel Wilson and the battle for the best plus size rom com (11:46) and the spinoff of The Walking Dead that no one asked for (17:03). They mention Kanye’s personal Blexit (20:53) and Spice Girls lack of posh (23:25) before it’s finally time for the feature presentation: Bohemian Rhapsody (25:48). They talk about Queen, Rami Malek and fact versus...