Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
True Crime
Discover the true stories behind the events that shocked and scandalized our ancestors. By mixing the resources and methods used in genealogy research with true crime accounts, Mindy Hudson pieces together interesting stories about the lives of ordinary people who were caught up in extraordinary circumstances.
Location:
United States
Description:
Discover the true stories behind the events that shocked and scandalized our ancestors. By mixing the resources and methods used in genealogy research with true crime accounts, Mindy Hudson pieces together interesting stories about the lives of ordinary people who were caught up in extraordinary circumstances.
Language:
English
Email:
melindamaloo@gmail.com
Episodes
The Jaded Love Murders: Meloy/Greenhill-Uren (1901)
5/1/2024
Mrs. Sadie Greenhill Uren was a pretty, young divorcee' whose newfound freedom also brought the attention of several eligible young men to her door. Her delight about this turn of events was not shared by her brothers, Will and Dan Greenhill, who would rather have seen her dead than to be living so scandalously. On the night of September 28, 1901, a visit from suitor John Meloy ended in a bizarre tragedy that made that wish come true.
And the only man who may have known what really happened wasn't talking.
Resources used:
Ancestry.com
Findagrave.com
Newspapers.com
sos.mo.gov
Social media:
Facebook - Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram - mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Email - melindamaloo@gmail.com
YouTube: Old-fashioned murder and mayhem@mindylou322
New content available for Assistant Sleuth and Genealogy Sleuth Members.
About me: Retired as head of genealogy from Jefferson County Library, Missouri. Storyteller at heart.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:21:32
First, Do No Harm: The Murder of James Lebeouf (1927)
4/1/2024
The Great Mississippi Flood of 1927 brought more than destructive high water to the South Louisiana town of Morgan City--it also brought the tangled web of a love triangle turned murder!
Resources used:
Ancestry.com
Findagrave.com
Newspapers.com
Social media:
Facebook - Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram - mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Email - melindamaloo@gmail.com
YouTube: Old-fashioned murder and mayhem@mindylou322
New content available for Assistant Sleuth and Genealogy Sleuth Members.
About me: Retired as head of genealogy from Jefferson County Library, Missouri. Storyteller at heart.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:35:42
Desperate Desire: The Kidnapping of Corinne Modell (1924)
3/1/2024
On a sunny afternoon in 1924, Eva Modell wheeled her 10-week-old baby girl outside the family's Philadelphia shop to get a little sun while she napped. It only took a moment of distraction and the baby was gone!
Who stole little Corinne and why? Would the family ever find their precious daughter alive?
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:23:03
The Mummified Lord: The Astonishing Story of Sidney Lascelles (alias Lord Walter Beresford)
2/1/2024
For six years the mysterious mummy dubbed "The Lord" was housed at the Noland Brown Company Undertakers in Asheville, North Carolina. When his identity was finally revealed, he turned out to be one of the most notorious con artists of all time!
Resources used:
Ancestry.com
Findagrave.com
Newspapers. com
Social media:
Facebook - Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram - mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Email - melindamaloo@gmail.com
About me: Retired as head of genealogy from Jefferson County Library, Missouri. Storyteller at heart.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:32:37
Die with it in you: The Legend of Frankie Silver (1831)
1/1/2024
For over two centuries, the mountain folks of North Carolina have been intrigued by the legend of Frankie Silver a young woman sentenced to hang for the axe murder and burning of her husband Charley Silver. What was the secret she took with her to her grave? And why has the story captured the imagination of so many generations of poets, storytellers, and musicians?
Listener discretion is advised.
Included in the episode is the original song "Frankie Silver (Take it to the Grave)" performed by Couldn't Be Happiers (featuring Brown Mountain Lightening Bugs on banjo and backup vocals).
Used by permission.
Songwriters: Jodi Hildebran (BMI) and Jordan Crosby Lee (ASCAP)
Publishers:
BMI- Eddie C Life Music
ASCAP- Mediterranean Sun
Sync rights: Music of the Sea
https://couldntbehappiers.com/
*
"Francis Silvers' Confession"
The Lenoir Topic
North Carolina
Wednesday, March 24, 1886
This dreadful, dark and dismal day
Has swept my glories all away.
My sun goes down, my days are past,
And I must leave this world at last.
Oh! Lord, what will become of me?
I am condemned you all now see,
To heaven or hell my soul must fly
All in a moment when I die.
Judge Daniel has my sentence pass'd
Those prison walls I leave at last,
Nothing to cheer my drooping head
Until I'm numbered with the dead.
But oh! that Dreadful Judge I fear;
Shall I that awful sentence hear:
"Depart ye cursed down to hell
And forever there to dwell"?
I know that frightful ghosts I'll see
Gnawing their flesh in misery,
And then and there attended be
For murder in the first degree.
There shall I meet that mournful face
Whose blood I spilled upon this place;
With flaming eyes to me he'll say,
"Why did you take my life away?"
His feeble hands fell gently down,
His chattering tongue soon lost its sound,
To see his soul and body part
It strikes with terror to my heart.
I took his blooming days away,
Left him no time to God to pray,
And if his sins fall on his head
Must I not bear them in his stead?
The jealous thought that first gave strife
To make me take my husband's life,
For months and days I spent my time
Thinking how to commit this crime.
And on a dark and doleful night
I put his body out of sight,
With flames I tried him to consume,
But time would not admit it done.
You all see me and on me gaze,
Be careful how you spend your days,
And never commit this awful crime,
But try to serve your God in time.
My mind on solemn subjects roll;
My little child, God bless its soul!
All you that are of Adams race,
Let not my faults this child disgrace.
Farewell good people, you all now see
What my bad conduct's brought on me--
To die of shame and disgrace
Before this world of human race.
*
Social media:
Facebook - Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram - mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Email - melindamaloo@gmail.com
About me: Retired as head of genealogy from Jefferson County Library, Missouri. Storyteller at heart.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:48:24
A Murder in Baby Bohemia: Gordon Pirie (1925)
12/1/2023
Best friends Gordon and George had known one another since childhood. What could have happened that left one dead and the other with blood on his hands? Find out the details in this story set in the roaring 20's of New York's Bronx.
Listener discretion is advised.
Resources used:
Ancestry.com
Fold3.com
Findagrave.com
Newspapers.com
Familysearch.org
Social media:
Facebook - Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram - mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Email - melindamaloo@gmail.com
About me: Retired as head of genealogy from Jefferson County Library, Missouri.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:20:31
Bad Seed: Jimmie M. Brock
11/1/2023
In the Depression-era South, Jimmie Brock left a trail of death behind him that destroyed his family and shook a small community to its core on the Louisiana and Mississippi border.
Resources used:
Ancestry.com
Fold3.com
Findagrave.com
Newspapers.com
Familysearch.org
Social media:
Facebook - Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram - mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Email - melindamaloo@gmail.com
About me: Retired as head of genealogy from Jefferson County Library, Missouri.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:15:15
The Newlywed Murders: Louis and Josephine Bonacker (1884)
10/1/2023
Louis and Josephine Bonacker had only been married six weeks when they made the mistake of inviting a traveler into their home in Jefferson County, Missouri that cold January in 1884. Two days passed before their mutilated bodies were discovered.
The Bonacker massacre is one of the most horrifying tales in the county's history.
Resources used:
Ancestry.com
Fold3.com
Findaagrave.com
Newspapers.com
Familysearch.org
Social media:
Facebook - Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram - mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Email - melindamaloo@gmail.com
About me: Retired as head of genealogy from Jefferson County Library, Missouri.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:27:00
Love and Murder: William Benson (1888)
9/1/2023
Everything 19-year-old William Benson dreamed of was there for the taking--a nice farm and a pretty wife. All he had to do was kill the couple who stood in his way.
Resources used:
Ancestry.com
Fold3.com
Findaagrave.com
Newspapers.com
Familysearch.org
Social media:
Facebook - Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram - mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Email - melindamaloo@gmail.com
About me: Retired as head of genealogy from Jefferson County Library, Missouri.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:17:55
Little Girl in Pink: Mary Daly (1925)
8/1/2023
A copycat crime, a case of mistaken identity, and a mentally deranged youth were the ingredients that formed the tragic story of Little Girl in Pink: Mary Daly (1925).
WARNING: Viewer discretion is advised.
Resources used:
Ancestry.com
Newspapers.com
Findagrave.com
The Shocking Criminal Case of Leopold and Loeb - https://youtu.be/4xjLJPGOI8o
These Spoiled Rich Kids Kill for Fun - https://youtu.be/VxW5qmQD80M
The Atlantic Magazine (June 1926) - https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/toc/1926/06/
Social media:
Facebook - Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram - mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Email - melindamaloo@gmail.com
About me: Retired as head of genealogy from Jefferson County Library, Missouri.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:28:00
The Schoolmarm Murder: Louise Gerrish (1924)
7/1/2023
On May 21, 1924, the rural town of Amherst, Maine was shocked to discover their 19-year-old school teacher was brutally murdered. The identity of the murderer and the ghastly details of the killing left the entire country asking "What is wrong with our young people?"
Sources used include:
Ancestry.com
Newspapers.com
Findagrave.com
Crime scene photographs from Woods Detective Agency, Boston - https://hollisarchives.lib.harvard.edu/repositories/5/archival_objects/1816831#:~:text=Part%20of%20the,law.harvard.edu, ITEM — Box: 5, Folder: 7 Identifier: HOLLIS004386789, 5-1 to 5-73, 5-7.
Social media:
Facebook - Old Fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram - mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:24:58
Beauty is the Beast: Winona Olena Spriggs (1924)
6/1/2023
When 55-year-old Robert Green was found murdered by the railroad tracks in Little Rock, Arkansas one August night in 1924, the only clue was the presence of a woman's footprints and a tiny rhinestone buckle discovered at the scene. The murderess was dubbed "the most beautiful woman ever to enter the Arkansas penitentiary."
But this was only the beginning of her story!
Host, Mindy Hudson, retired head of the genealogy department at Jefferson County Library, Missouri. Using resources and methods typical in genealogy research, I piece together the stories of the lives of people involved in historical true crime across America.
Resources used include:
Ancestry.com
Newspapers.com
Social media:
Youtube: oldfashionedmurderandmayhem@mindylou322
Facebook: Old fashioned Murder and Mayhem
Instagram: mindys_murder_and_mayhem
Email: melindamaloo@gmail.com
Also check out the podcast "Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri" on your favorite podcast venue for more stories by Mindy.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:41:33
The Boy Who Fell from the Sky: Charles Henry Bennett (1889)
5/1/2023
Tornado season in the Midwest can leave a trail of destruction as powerful winds suck up everything in its path. Hear the story of how a Missouri boy was swept into a cyclone and delivered to a childless couple in 1889.
It took eighteen years for the story of Charles Henry Bennett to be revealed. Hear the remarkable saga of a young man's search for his identity.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:19:31
Forbidden Love: Francis Asbury Hawkins (1887)
4/1/2023
Francis Asbury Hawkins, the eldest son of the upper echelon of Long Island society, made the faux pax of falling in love with the wrong girl. Set in Long Island, New York in 1887, hear the story of love, class division, and murder!
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:38:06
Fire, Blood, & Water: The Frank McDowell Story (1923-24)
3/1/2023
The date of February 19th was a curse for the McDowell family of Georgia. Was it mental illness or pure evil that struck on that fateful winter day? Decide for yourself as we explore the chilling story of Frank McDowell, the Holy Ghost Killer.
Resources used include:
Ancestry.com
Newspapers.com
Findagrave.com
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:39:20
River Justice: Helen Ruth Spence Eaton (1934)
2/1/2023
Discover how the 1934 murder of a seemingly insignificant river girl brought down the corrupt Arkansas Penal System in the fascinating tale of the short life of Helen Spence Eaton of the White River.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:39:44
Little Boy Lost: Frank Raymond Deford (1944)
1/9/2023
When Andrew and Gertrude Kley accepted to foster 12-year-old Frank Deford in their Cedar Hill, Missouri home in 1943, they could not have imagined the monster behind the angelic, freckled face. Unfortunately, they discovered how far the lad would go to get what he wanted, and murder wasn't out of the question.
Learn the story of young Frank Deford's descent into a life of crime and insanity. In this episode of Old-Fashioned Murder and Mayhem, we'll explore the background of Deford's life and follow him from the boys' gangs of St. Louis to his stints at Leavenworth and Alcatraz.
Be sure to visit our sister site Murder and Mayhem in Jefferson County, Missouri for more tales of historical local true crime.
Duration:00:28:17