Justice with John Carpay

John Carpay discusses a double standard he sees in the application of the law. He cites the case of Derek Reimer, a Calgary pastor who has been convicted of causing a disturbance after protesting drag queen story hours at public libraries. John points out numerous cases of protests that caused disturbances, many in front of police, where no one is ever charged. We then focus on petitions. Do they do any good? Then we talk about the controversial Court Challenges Program. Finally, we look at a new study showing that children in this post-Covid era are having difficulty paying attention in school. John Carpay in the Epoch Times via the Justice Centre, Jan 27, 2025: Everyone Should Be Equal Under the Law CBC, Jun 2, 2020: Hundreds gather for Black Lives Matter solidarity rally in Regina CBC, Jun 22, 2022: Queen Victoria statue beheaded by protesters can't be repaired, Manitoba government says CBC, Feb 14, 2020: Trudeau calls for 'dialogue' as blockade cripples rail network, while Scheer says clear out the protesters Global News, Feb 14, 2022: Trudeau invokes Emergencies Act for 1st time to aid convoy blockade response Justice Centre, Aug 11, 2023: R. v. Whatcott - Challenging expanding definitions of “hate speech” in Canada John Carpay in the Western Standard via the Justice Centre, Dec 30, 2024: An election in 2025 will not fix Canada’s cultural decline Amazon: Corrupted by Fear: How the Charter was betrayed, and what Canadians can do about it by John Carpay Justice Centre, Jan 24, 2025: Why Petitions? Justice Centre, Apr 9, 2024: Justice Centre delivers 50,000+ petition signatures against Online Harms Act in Ottawa Justice Centre, Jan 9, 2025: Canadians challenge Prime Minister’s decision to prorogue Parliament Blacklock's Reporter, Jan 22, 2025: Feds Paid Carbon Tax Friends Blacklock's Reporter, Jan 23, 2025: Carbon Tax A ‘Human Right’ The Epoch Times, Jan 23, 2025: Youths’ Rudeness in Classroom ‘Significantly Higher’ Following COVID-19 School Shutdowns: Study Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Photo credit: CBC - Brangwyn Jones Support the show

John Carpay starts off by reading an interesting X post asserting that wokeism is not dead, despite all the commentary that the ideology is on the way out. Then, he points to a news story about the 15,000+ Canadians who died last year while on healthcare waiting lists. Finally, we discuss a 13-minute political attack ad, paid for by the City of Pickering, that goes after one of their own, City Councillor Lisa Robinson. Nathan Cofnas on X, Jan 14, 2025: On the end of woke The Epoch Times, Jan 16, 2025: As University of Alberta Steps Back From DEI, Will Others Follow Suit? National Post, Jan 16, 2025: In latest sign of woke retreat, Starbucks walks back 'anti-racist' bathroom policy Justice with John Carpay, Dec 3, 2024: Does DEI violate the Charter? secondstreet.org, Jan 15, 2025: 15,474 Canadians Died Waiting for Health Care in 2023-24 Supreme Court of Canada, Jun 9, 2005: Chaoulli v. Quebec (Attorney General) Justice Centre, Jun 21, 2013: Access to health care: Darcy Allen’s story Justice Centre, Oct 15, 2019: Constitutional challenge to the Alberta’s health care monopoly and waiting lists True North, Jan 2, 2025: Pickering cancels public town hall meetings citing “alt-right” infiltration Durham Region News, Jan 10, 2025: OPP investigating after Pickering council launches complaint against Lisa Robinson AntiHate.ca, Nov 29, 2023: German MEP Christine Anderson Forced To Find New Venue For Ottawa Stop CBC, May 8, 2018: New anti-hate group aims to monitor 'growing threat' of far-right extremists in Canada National Post, Oct 18, 2023: The conspicuous silence of the Canadian Anti-Hate Network Spotify, Justice with John Carpay, Jan 9, 2023: Season 4 Episode 1 John in Jail genius.com: The Fifth of November (Guy Fawkes Night Poem) IMdB: V for Vendetta Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

This show, we start off by discussing the court action against the Prime Minister's decision to prorogue Parliament - filed the day after the PM's press conference. Then, John highlights a story out of British Columbia, where some are calling for an investigation of potential voting fraud in the last provincial election. The allegations concern a riding where the difference between winning and losing was just 22 votes. John gives his five rules for free and fair elections. Justice Centre, Jan 7, 2025: Canadians challenge Prime Minister’s decision to prorogue Parliament: “no reasonable justification” Justice Centre, Jan 18, 2025: Federal Court grants urgent hearing in case against decision to prorogue Parliament Justice Centre YouTube Playlist: The case against proroguing Parliament National Post, Jan 7, 2025: Two men file unprecedented legal challenge against Trudeau's request for prorogation CBC, Jan 9, 2025: Trudeau's move to suspend Parliament faces a legal challenge. Don't hold your breath for a win, experts say Conservative MP Michelle Ferreri with Christopher Dummitt on Facebook: What did the Governor General do wrong? Canadian Press via Halifax City News, Jan 9, 2025: CRTC to hold hearing on impact of global streamers on Canadian broadcasting Western Standard, Jan 13, 2025: BC Conservatives call for RCMP investigation into 'voting irregularities' in Surrey-Guildford Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

We at the Justice with John Carpay podcast take it easy at the end of the year. Instead of our usual conversation, we’ll play a recording of a mid-December Zoom meeting with our donors. Marcie Clare, the Justice Centre’s Events and Special Projects Coordinator, hosts. The meeting was a recap of all the work we did in 2024, and mixed in is a bit of a preview of what's coming up in 2025. It features presentations by President John Carpay, Litigation Director Marty Moore and Luke Neilson, Director of Communications. Our Public Meetings page: This is where you find details and purchase tickets to any upcoming meetings in your area. Our Networking Events page. We post notices of our "In Converstation" networking events here. The George Jonas Freedom Award has its own section. You can find info about past recipients here. It will be updated with upcoming dates and locations for the 2025 dinners as details become available. Justice Centre High School Courses: Enhance your understanding of Charter rights and freedoms with our developing high school courses. Our papers on various topics, grouped by subjects, can be found on the Reports and Analyses page. The winners of our 2024 essay contest can be found here. The winners of our 2024 art contest are here. We are very proud of our "Explore the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms" page which presents an easy-to-navigate version of the Charter. The Podcast page on our website gives you quick access to our weekly show. Our active files, as well as the concluded ones, can be found on the "Our Cases" page. News Releases are grouped chronologically on another page. Opinions & Columns by John Carpay and other staff lawyers have their own page. On our Who We Are page you can find staff bios, mission statements, as well as links to all annual reports and Dockets lower down Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

John Carpay discusses his new book, Corrupted by Fear: How the Charter was betrayed, and what Canadians can do about it. The eBook is now available for pre-order on Amazon. Though John has been publishing opinion pieces and columns for decades, this is his first book. He gives us some insight into what inspired him to write it. He then reads the Introduction, which describes the plan and purpose of the work. And finally, we talk about the book's last section, entitled, "Defeating Modern Fascism." Amazon.ca: Corrupted by Fear: How the Charter was betrayed, and what Canadians can do about it by John Carpay Epoch Times, Dec 11, 2024: 1 in 3 Canadians Say Government Overreacted to COVID Pandemic: Survey Toronto CityNews, Dec 2, 2024: Scouts Canada survey reveals concerns about social skills of COVID-era kids "In 2023-24, the government is expecting to record expenses to the tune of about C$16.4 billion related to Indigenous contingent liabilities and C$4.7 billion related to the COVID-19 pandemic, which pushed its deficit figures higher, the fiscal update said." Reuters via MSN, Dec 16, 2024: Canada overshoots deficit target by C$20 billion as finance minister resigns CTV News, Jan 24, 2023: 'We were looked upon as monsters': COVID-19 vaccine policies at Ont. hospitals keep health workers from filling staff shortages Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

To open the show, Kevin asks John if Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) policies violate the equality provisions in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. This leads to a discussion about the cultural shift away from DEI among large corporations in the US, both before and after the recent presidential election. Canada is lagging behind. We end by focusing on the debate over changes to the Alberta Bill of Rights, which has those who normally agree about freedom in Canada disagreeing. Justice Centre, Aug 9, 2024: Harvest Ministries suing Québec government for forcing event cancellation Government of Canada: Diversity and inclusion in the public service CanLII, Jun 27, 2008: R. v. Kapp, 2008 SCC 41 National Post, Nov 25, 2021: Minority professor denied grants because he hires on merit: 'People are afraid to think' The Independent, Jun 13, 2024: Republicans push bill to ban DEI programs from federal agencies and stop schools using federal funds for them National Post, Feb 19, 2024: Can job postings in Canada exclude white people? Short answer: yes Calgary Sun, Nov 28, 2024: Liberal party not saying if it verifies Indigenous identity of candidates, despite outcry Global News via MSN, Nov 26, 2024: Government suspends Boissonnault’s former company from obtaining federal contracts Blacklock's Reporter, Nov 29, 2024: Fake Claims “Very Common” Newsweek, Nov 26, 2024: Walmart to Toyota: Major Companies Rolling Back DEI Policies CBC, Nov 22, 2024: Ontario Human Rights Tribunal fines Emo Township for refusing Pride proclamation Justice Centre, Aug 10, 2020: PARLA v. Prince Albert John Carpay in the Epoch Times via the Justice Centre, Nov 26, 2024: Ultimately, protecting fundamental freedoms depends on a citizenry that cherishes a free and virtuous society The Lavigne Show on Rumble, Nov 27, 2024: Danielle's Legacy w/ Leighton Grey, Marty Belanger, Bruce Pardy & Marty Moore Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

John and Kevin discuss the requirement that drivers headed to the United States will have to submit photo ID and biometric data in advance. Why is this necessary, and how does this requirement tie in with concerns about digital ID? John and Kevin then discuss a column of John's in which he puts forward the idea that our constitution might protect us from globalist intrusions. And finally, we examine a recent instance of compelled speech, where the federal government has introduced legislation that will force pregnancy crisis centres to promote abortion. NTD, Nov 14, 2024: Canadians to Pre-Submit Digital Photo, Driver’s Licence for Border Crossings in 2026: Federal Report Western Standard, Nov 14, 2024: ‘BIOMETRIC DECLARATION’: Digital ID for Canadians driving into US by 2026 Immigration and Citizenship, Government of Canada: Biometrics--Where to give your fingerprints and photo Immigration and Citizenship, Government of Canada: Find out if you need to give biometrics CBC, Jan 24, 2022: Canada planning technological fixes to make crossing the border faster USA Today, Oct 17, 2024: Is it safe to share biometric data? Tech expert weighs in Justice Centre, Concluded Case, Oct 18, 2023: Constitutional challenge of Canada’s mandatory use of ArriveCAN app IMdB: Shake Hands with the Devil (2007) CanLII, Aug 20: Reference re Secession of Quebec, 1998 CanLII 793 Supreme Court of Canada, Sep 9, 1981: Re: Resolution to amend the Constitution, 1981 CanLII 25 Alissa Golob in the National Post, Nov 12, 2024: Liberals only interested in a woman's right to an abortion — not choice National Post, Nov 1, 2024: Liberals take 'softer approach' on pledge to revoke charity status for pregnancy counselling Justice Centre, Jun 30, 2021: BCM International v. Canada Global News, Sep 11, 2019: Ontario law society repeals rule requiring members to commit to promoting diversity Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

Lawyer Marty Moore takes us through the good and the bad of proposed changes to Alberta's Education Act. There is a lot in here that firmly establishes parental rights and puts some serious guardrails around gender transitions for minors. Parents will now have to opt-in to explicit sex education in the classroom. However, the Education Act will allow sex education to occur without parental notification during activities and in groups occurring outside the classroom. This means that explicit sexual material could be easily shared by activists with young kids on field trips, at assemblies, and in any group that meets outside of class time, and parents may never hear about it. The opt-in provisions will give parents a false sense of control over what their kids are learning. Alberta Government, Oct 31, 2024: Supporting Alberta students and families--Proposed amendments to the Education Act will support student success and well-being in Alberta schools. CBC, Oct 31, 2024: Alberta tables bills on transgender youth health care, students' pronouns, opt-in sex education Justice Centre Achievement, Oct 19, 2019: Challenging the constitutionality of secrecy in schools Justice Centre, Jan 18, 2019: Affidavit of B.B. Justice Centre, Jun 26, 2019: Affidavit of J.J. (autistic student re: Firefly event) Justice Centre, Feb 12, 2019: Affidavit of A.A. NPR, Feb 14, 2023: Some Kansas lawmakers want to punish doctors who help transgender kids transition The Audit, Apr 17, 2024: Who Will Underwrite the Legal Liability for Puberty Blocker Harms? Daily Mail, Mar 13, 2024: 'America needs to wake up': Doctors and politicians praise England's 'landmark decision' to ban puberty blockers for children over fears about drugs' long-term harms - as they call for similar in US Forbes, Jun 14, 2023: Increasing Number Of European Nations Adopt A More Cautious Approach To Gender-Affirming Care Among Minors Government of Saskatchewan, Oct 20, 2023: "Parents' Bill Of Rights" Passed And Enshrined In Legislation Chris Selley in The National Post via MSN, Nov 1, 2024: The war over transitioning kids is still blazing in New Brunswick Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

Lawyer James Manson brings us up to date on the $290 million lawsuit brought by Ottawa resident Zexi Li and others against the Freedom Convoy. In court on Oct 28, Mr. Manson put forward his arguments in an appeal against the dismissal of his Anti-SLAPP motion that would have ended the lawsuit. It's still early days, he says, but he's already put forward some interesting evidence, like the fact that it was the Ottawa police, and not the truckers, that created the traffic problems in downtown Ottawa back in January and February 2022. Justice Centre, Oct 25, 2024: On Monday, court will hear arguments in $290 million lawsuit against Freedom Convoy Justice Centre Active Case, Feb 5, 2024: Zexi Li launches $290 million lawsuit against Freedom Convoy participants Justice Centre, Aug 8, 2023: Update on Anti-SLAPP Motion in Class Action Lawsuit against Freedom Convoy Participants Justice Centre, Feb 7, 2024: Justice Centre in court today opposing application against organizers of Freedom Convoy Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP, Sep 14, 2020: Supreme Court rearticulates test under Ontario “anti-SLAPP” legislation Superior Court of Ontario: Best Practices Guide For Class Actions in Ontario Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

We discuss a recent Ontario Court of Appeal decision, Mathur v. Ontario, which was the subject of a recent National Post column by Jamie Sarkonak. In this case, a group of teenagers had gone after the Ford government when it lowered the CO2 targets created by the previous government. The kids claimed the change in government policy violated their Charter rights by endangering the future. The teenagers lost the first round, but now the Appeal Court has ordered a new trial, indirectly suggesting they might have a right to a stable climate. Court of Appeal for Ontario, Oct 17, 2024: Mather v. Ontario Jamie Sarkonak in the National Post, Oct 22, 2024: Court says lack of economy-killing climate targets may violate the Charter Supreme Court of Canada, Apr 2, 2024: Vriend v. Alberta Friends of Science, Aug 6, 2019: Alligators in Alaska Ken Gregory in Friends of Science, Jun 14, 2024: Climate Sensitivity by Energy Balance with Urban and Natural Warming (PDF) CanLII, Jun 20, 2024: Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act, SC 2018, c 12, s 186 Supreme Court of Canada, May 25, 2021: References re Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act Financial Times, Feb 21, 2015: Chairman of climate change panel accused of sexual harassment Wikipedia: Rajendra K. Pachauri BBC, Feb 24, 2015: Profile: Climate chief Rajendra Pachauri Carbon Brief, Jan 12, 2023: Tonga volcano eruption raises ‘imminent’ risk of temporary 1.5C breach Watts Up With That?, Aug 24, 2024: Climate Change Weekly #516: Hunga Tonga Eruption Behind “Record” Warming Kenneth P. Green, Fraser Institute Bulletin, Apr 2024: Extreme Weather and Climate Change (PDF) CanLII, Sep 9, 2021: O.M.S. v E.J.S., 2021 SKQB 243 (Ruling by M.T. Megaw) Justice Centre Concluded Case, May 11, 2023: Trinity Bible Chapel, et al. v. Ontario Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

John shares his thoughts on a National Post column criticizing recent statements from Supreme Court Chief Justice Richard Wagner. He agrees that undermining the value of legal precedent harms the rule of law. John also discusses a column in which he supports adding the right to refuse a vaccine to the Alberta Bill of Rights, as proposed by Premier Danielle Smith. He argues that while the Charter theoretically protects rights, judges too often side with governments. Stéphane Sérafin and Kerry Sun in the National Post, Oct 9, 2024: Unchecked judicial power — that's Chief Justice Wagner's vision for Canada Supreme Court of Canada, Jan 27, 1959: Roncarelli v. Duplessis Supreme Court of Canada, May 17, 2001: Trinity Western University v. British Columbia College of Teachers Supreme Court of Canada, Jun 15, 2018: Law Society of British Columbia v. Trinity Western University John Carpay in The Epoch Times via the Justice Centre, Oct 11, 2024: Canadians Need Legislation to Protect Their Rights The Canadian Press via the National Post, Sep 24, 2024: Danielle Smith announces details of planned Alberta Bill of Rights that includes vaccine choice, gun ownership Fox News, Dec 3, 2021: Canadian judge stays compelled speech order issued against pastor whenever he speaks publicly about COVID-19 CanLII, Sep 9, 2021: O.M.S. v E.J.S., 2021 SKQB 243 Justice Centre Active Case, Sep 19, 2024: Challenging constitutionality of Ontario’s public health orders - Hillier v. Ontario Justice Centre Concluded Case, May 11, 2023: Trinity Bible Chapel, et al. v. Ontario Justice Centre Report, Sep 13, 2022: Excess Deaths Contradict Narrative of Success Justice Centre Concluded Case, Mar 13, 2024: Challenging Manitoba’s lockdown measures - Gateway Bible Baptist Church, et al. v. Manitoba and Chief Public Health Officer Dr. Brent Roussin CTV News, Sep 27, 2021: Alberta NDP calls for door-to-door vaccination campaign to increase immunizations Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

Justice Centre President John Carpay shares his perspective on the residential school system and on NDP MP Leah Gazan's Private Members' Bill (Bill C-413), which would make it a Criminal Code offence to condone, deny, downplay, or justify the residential school system. He discusses the potential impact of this Bill on freedom of expression, the Truth and Reconciliation project, and what he thinks is required for true reconciliation in Canada. National Post, Sep 26, 2024: NDP MP tables bill seeking to criminalize residential school 'denialism' Blacklock's Reporter, Sep 27, 2024: MP Seeks Jail For ‘Denialism’ Rose LeMay in Hill Times, Oct 8, 2024: Residential school denialism should be illegal The Canadian Press via CTV, Nov 26, 2023: Special interlocutor 'waiting' for MP bill criminalizing residential school denialism Leah Gazan on X, Oct 27, 2022: (this is her introducing her motion to get residential schools considered genocide) Tristan Hopper in National Post, Oct 1, 2024: All the times the current Parliament has tried to limit free expression Mark Milke in the National Post, Oct 3, 2024: Criminalizing residential school 'denialism' would silence Indigenous voices, too Woke Watch Canada Substack, Feb 3, 2024: Why Indigenous Land Acknowledgments are Harmful to the Public Interest Jonathan Kay in Quillette, Jun 20, 2023: In Canada, Asking for Evidence Now Counts as ‘Denialism’ National Post Editorial, Jun 24, 2023: Criminalizing speech the wrong way to address residential school legacy Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show

Justice Centre President John Carpay returns to the show to tell us about the book he's writing with the working title "Corrupted by Fear." It's about Canadian court judgments in constitutional challenges to the many Covid restrictions over the last 4 years. Judges, he's found, relied heavily on fear driven media narratives. He also discusses two recent and related columns, "COVID-19 in Italy, what actually happened?" and "Will we fall for the same old PCR tricks again?" Justice Centre, Mar 13, 2024: Challenging Manitoba’s lockdown measures John Carpay in the Western Standard via the Justice Centre, Sep 14, 2024: COVID-19 in Italy, what actually happened? Xinhuanet, Feb 11, 2020: I am human, NOT virus! Stories behind trending anti-racism videos after novel coronavirus outbreak The Atlantic, Apr 8, 2020: An Unimaginable Toll Justice Centre, May 11, 2021: Manitoba Chief Microbiologist and Laboratory Specialist: 56% of positive “cases” are not infectious Justice Centre, Apr 29, 2020: Chief Medical Officers questioned on lockdown’s adverse health impacts CTV News, Oct 14, 2021: Hinshaw apologizes after Alberta mistakenly reports 14-year-old's cancer death was caused by COVID-19 Bonnie Henry: Reconsideration decision John Carpay in the Western Standard, Sep 5, 2024: Covid Apocalypse and the triumph of fear over facts Justice Centre Report, Dec 3, 2020: Flying Blind - Governments’ hasty decisions to lock down Canadians while damaging public health and the economy Scientific American, Apr 29, 2021: Flu Has Disappeared for More Than a Year WHO, Jun 7, 2020: Medical certification, ICD mortality coding, and reporting mortality associated with COVID-19 CBC, Sep 9, 2024: Alberta's COVID-19 death toll more than 4 times higher than flu over past year Global, Sep 11, 2024: New Alberta COVID data highlights value of getting newly formulated vaccine once available: expert George Jonas Freedom Award dinner in Calgary on Friday, September 27, 2024 Theme Music "Carpay Diem" by Dave Stevens Support the show