Brain in a Vat
Philosophy Podcasts
Thought experiments and conversations with philosophers. Hosted by Dr Jason Werbeloff and Mark Oppenheimer.
Location:
United States
Genres:
Philosophy Podcasts
Description:
Thought experiments and conversations with philosophers. Hosted by Dr Jason Werbeloff and Mark Oppenheimer.
Language:
English
Website:
https://anchor.fm/braininavat
Episodes
Ethical Quandaries of Autonomous Weapon Systems | Afonso Seixas-Nunes
4/28/2024
We speak with Father Afonso about the use of weapon systems in warfare. The discussion explores a thought experiment involving two states at war and the deployment of autonomous drones capable of targeting terrorists without human intervention. Key topics include the legality and morality of such systems, the potential for reducing civilian casualties, the challenge of machine errors leading to war crimes, and the shifting responsibility in decision-making from humans to machines. The conversation also addresses the technological advances in AI, the issues of accountability and transparency with autonomous systems, and the philosophical implications of removing human judgment from warfare. We examine potential future scenarios where autonomous weapons could be misused by non-state actors or influenced by automation bias, raising critical questions about the control, ethics, and implications of advanced AI in military and civilian contexts.
[00:00] Introduction to the Episode and Guest Co-Host Jimmy Mullen
[00:12] Exploring Autonomous Weapon Systems with Father Afonso
[00:55] The Ethical and Legal Quandaries of Autonomous Weapons
[03:01] The Evolution of Warfare and Technology's Role
[06:15] The Human Element in Modern Warfare and AI
[08:19] The Philosophical and Legal Challenges of Autonomous Weapons
[21:08] Addressing Accountability and the Future of AI in Warfare
[30:17] Defining AI and Its Legal Challenges
[31:05] The Future of AI and Moral Agency
[31:51] AI's Emotional Intelligence and Superintelligence
[32:50] Military Strategy and AI: A New Conscience?
[34:21] The Limitations of AI in Understanding Common Sense
[36:13] The Human Element in AI Development
[37:03] Autonomous Weapons Systems and the Essence of Humanity
[39:11] AI on the Battlefield: Efficiency vs. Ethics
[43:37] The Unpredictability of AI and Warfare
[50:45] AI's Role Beyond the Battlefield
[56:27] The Collective Mind and Autonomous Systems
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:01:02:02
Paediatric Gender Medicine | Moti Gorin and Holly Lawford-Smith
4/21/2024
We begin by imagining a world where children are separated by sex at birth and raised without exposure to traditional gender norms. We debate whether gender incongruence is a result of nature or social conditioning. We discuss gender affirming care for children, highlighting the complexity of diagnosing gender dysphoria amidst co-occurring psychiatric conditions and the potential influence of social contagion. Key insights include questioning the lack of robust evidence for the efficacy of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones, and the need for comprehensive psychosocial care before considering medical transition. The Cass Review was released after we recorded our conversation, but we address similar concerns.
00:00 Introduction to the Thought Experiment
00:10 Exploring Gender Segregation and Its Impacts
02:22 Debating the Existence of Gender Incongruence
03:28 The Social Construction of Gender and Its Medical Implications
04:48 Sexual Orientation in a Segregated Society
13:37 Challenging the Medicalization of Gender Diversity
25:26 Transracialism and Personal Identity Choices
31:41 Medical Risks and Ethical Dilemmas in Gender Transition
41:38 Exploring the Regulation of Cross-Sex Hormones
42:11 The Uncertainty of Medical Interventions and Autonomy
44:49 The Complexities of Gender Dysphoria Treatment
45:43 Evaluating the Risks and Benefits of Paediatric Transition
48:39 The Debate on Consent and Medical Ethics
51:38 Addressing Comorbidities in Gender Dysphoria Treatment
58:45 The Role of Social Phenomena in Gender Dysphoria
01:11:17 Examining the Evidence and Ethics of Puberty Blockers
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:01:17:04
Peter Singer on Animal Liberation Now
4/14/2024
Peter Singer delves into difficult ethical questions regarding animal rights, the morality of factory farming, and difficult human-related ethical dilemmas.
Singer discusses his views as a consequentialist, examining the impact of our choices on animal suffering, the ethical considerations around organ donation from anencephalic children, and the broader implications of such decisions.
What are the moral implications of eating meat from factory farms versus ethically raised animals, and cannibalism under hypothetical scenarios with no harm to others?
Singer emphasizes the need for considering the consequences of our actions, shedding light on the pressing need to reform our food production systems and make more ethical choices in our daily lives.
Peter Singer’s Substack: https://substack.com/profile/4270932-peter-singer
Peter Singer’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@peter_singer
Peter Singer’s book, ‘Animal Liberation Now’: https://www.amazon.com/Animal-Liberation-Now-Definitive-Classic/dp/0063226707
00:00 A Philosophical Dive into Animal Rights with Peter Singer
00:12 Exploring the Ethical Dilemmas of Human and Animal Lives
01:59 The Complexities of Organ Donation from Anencephalic Children
03:57 Comparing Human and Animal Rights in Medical Contexts
06:08 Consequentialism and Individual Case Analysis in Ethics
07:42 The Ethical Quandaries of Parental Consent and Medical Decisions
15:54 Navigating the Slippery Slope of Euthanasia and Assisted Dying
25:41 The Ethical Considerations of Eating Meat and Factory Farming
33:29 The Harsh Realities of Factory Farming
34:45 Ethical Considerations and the Nature of Animal Suffering
36:50 Addressing Common Objections to Animal Rights
41:12 The Impact of Individual Choices on Animal Suffering
43:43 The Role of Vegetarianism and Veganism in Reducing Demand for Meat
01:00:46 Exploring the Ethical Implications of Consuming Expired or Discarded Meat
01:04:50 Concluding Thoughts and Reflections
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:01:05:15
We Should Want Immortality | John Martin Fischer
4/7/2024
John Martin Fischer argues that life constantly offers new experiences and perspectives that prevent it from becoming monotonous.
He delves into the idea of living a significantly extended life without aging and the implications it has on personal identity and society at large. Fischer distinguishes between true immortality and radical life extension, favoring the latter for its exit strategy options.
The conversation covers the value of life experiences, the philosophical questions around personal identity over time, and the ethical considerations of immortal life.
00:00 Introduction to Immortality with John Martin Fischer
00:16 The Library Analogy: Exploring the Concept of Living Forever
01:26 Challenging the Library Analogy: A New Perspective on Immortality
03:49 Addressing the Potential Fatigue of Immortality
06:52 The Elixir of Eternal Life: A Thought Experiment
09:03 The Philosophical Debate on the Ideal Age for Immortality
38:42 The Social and Ethical Implications of Immortality
48:34 Personal Choice vs. Societal Impact: The Immortality Dilemma
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:00:51:38
Against Immortality | Stephen Cave
3/31/2024
Stephen Cave unpacks the ethical and practical problems of living forever. He highlights ongoing research in anti-aging and the potential societal and ecological catastrophes that could follow if humans were to achieve immortality.
Stephen weighs the individual’s desire for immortality against social implications, and the potential exacerbation of social injustices. The discussion also addresses technological possibilities like consciousness uploading and the philosophical implications of personal identity, memory, and morality.
The conversation navigates the complexities of life extension technologies, questioning the nature of what it means to live a meaningful life.
00:00 Welcome to the Immortality Debate
00:27 Exploring the Possibility of Living Forever
01:57 The Ethical Dilemmas of Immortality
05:03 Addressing Overpopulation and Societal Collapse
07:26 The Underpopulation Counterargument
09:09 The Philosophical and Practical Aspects of Life Extension
11:23 Space Colonization: A Feasible Solution?
13:01 The Ethical Quandary of Life Extension Pills
19:04 Addressing Social Justice in the Context of Immortality
24:30 The Boredom Argument Against Immortality
28:08 Exploring the Infinite Possibilities of AI and Immortality
28:26 The Philosophical Dilemma of Immortality and Ennui
30:26 Considering the Ethics and Legality of Suicide
31:12 The Rationality of Suicide in an Immortal Life
32:44 The Sorites Paradox and Life Extension
34:02 The Practical Challenges of Life Extension Policies
34:58 Dystopian Scenarios in Immortality and Central Planning
37:27 The Concept of Personal Identity and Immortality
40:38 Consciousness Uploading: A Dystopian Idea?
45:23 Personal Identity, Memory, and Augmentation
49:01 The Philosophical Exploration of Ennui and Meaninglessness
53:00 Immortality in Mythology and the Quest for Novel Experiences
54:58 Reimagining Immortality and Embracing Finitude
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:00:56:12
Immigration and Borders | Stephen Kershnar
3/24/2024
Featuring Stephen Kershnar, we discuss the complexities of immigration ethics, the rights to immigrate, and the morality of borders, keeping in mind debates around wealth, exclusion, and property rights.
Stephen considers consequentialist and deontological perspectives in immigration policies, the notion of collective versus individual rights, and the philosophical implications on national identity and personal liberty.
00:00 Introduction and Guest Welcome
00:16 Discussion on Immigration
01:05 Thought Experiment on Immigration
02:57 Debate on Collective Ownership and Immigration
04:23 Exploring the Rights of Immigrants
04:34 Dilemma of Immigration in a Private Island Scenario
05:03 Debate on the Right to Life and Immigration
08:28 Discussion on Collective Decision Making
10:22 Exploring the Concept of Citizenship
11:18 Debate on Collective Ownership of a Country
20:09 Discussion on the Consequences of Immigration
27:46 Debate on National Self Interest and Immigration
34:39 Exploring the Concept of Citizenship
35:48 Analogies and Disanalogies in Citizenship
36:38 Consequences of Citizenship Revocation
37:34 Consequentialist Discussion on Immigration
39:15 The Utility of Immigration
41:46 The Right to Evict: A Discussion
42:01 The Case of Refugees and Birthright Citizenship
46:16 The Consequences of Open Borders
48:32 The Impact of Immigration on Population Growth
01:00:08 The Dilemma of Local Control and Freedom of Movement
01:06:42 The Value of Collective Property in Immigration
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:01:07:36
Cascading Catastrophic Risks | Trond Undheim
3/17/2024
Trond Undheim delves into catastrophic risks facing humanity, including climate change, governance breakdown, and technological threats.
Through discussions of risk perception, effective planning versus worry, and the complexities of managing existential threats, Trond emphasizes the importance of preparing and adapting for uncertain futures.
How should we think about potential future crises, the role of technology in exacerbating or mitigating risks, and the moral obligations of contemporary society to future generations?
00:00 Introduction and Guest Presentation
00:08 Imagining the World in 2075
00:26 The Impact of World Conflicts and Climate Change
01:03 The Rise of Organized Crime and Economic Divide
02:08 The Future of Medical Technologies and Lifespan
02:54 Reflections on the Turning Point of the Century
04:14 Understanding Risk and Worry
04:53 The Role of Planning and Thriving in Risk Management
06:35 The Potential of Giga Projects and Modular Solutions
07:40 The Dilemma of Investing in Uncertain Events
08:41 The Existential Risk of Asteroid Collision
11:27 The Responsibility of Future Generations
13:49 The Complexity of Catastrophic Risk
22:13 The Potential Risks by 2075
46:01 The Role of Community in Risk Mitigation
47:41 The Challenge of Collective Action in Preventing Catastrophe
53:25 Conclusion: The Importance of Good Intent in Systemic Understanding
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:00:54:40
The Ethics of Political Commemoration | Hans Gutbrod
3/10/2024
In this episode of 'Brain In A Vat', Hans Gutbrod addresses the gap in philosophy in understanding the ethics around statues, street names, and museums.
By drawing parallels to just war theory, Gutbrod proposes a framework to navigate the complexities of commemorating historical figures and events. The discussion also touches upon the potential for altering commemorative symbols to preserve memory while adapting their messages.
This episode probes the moral and aesthetic considerations of how societies remember their past.
00:00 Introduction and Thought Experiment
01:31 The Gap in Philosophy and Ethics
02:47 The Ethics of Representations of the Past
03:19 The Role of Metaphysics in Commemoration
03:48 The Influence of History and Philosophy on Commemoration
04:42 The Impact of Statues and Memorials on Public Perception
06:30 The Ethics of Political Commemoration
09:38 The Criteria for Erecting and Keeping Statues
10:36 The Role of Intent in Commemoration
12:11 The Role of Empirical Research in Commemoration
13:17 The Challenges of Commemorating the Past
15:05 The Complexity of Commemoration
19:04 The Scope and Vagueness of Commemoration
21:54 The Role of Conversation in Commemoration
26:38 The Role of Vagueness in Commemoration
28:05 The Complexity of Erecting Statues
28:32 Perspectives from the Caucasus
28:58 Reframing the Debate: The Case of Georgia
30:00 Street Names and Shadows of the Past
30:57 The Role of Art in Commemoration
31:43 The Sackler Controversy and the Power of Art
32:40 The Value of Preservation and Enriching Debate
33:06 The Risk of Over-Inclusivity
33:29 The Osama Bin Laden Hypothetical
34:54 Addressing the Vagueness Problem
36:20 The Ethics of Political Commemoration
37:56 The Challenge of Deciding on Statues
41:30 The Power of Artistic Alteration
45:53 The Holocaust Memorial in Berlin: A Case Study
53:12 The Role of Aesthetics in Commemoration
55:31 The Personal Engagement with Commemoration
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:00:56:51
Facial Distortions and Prosopometamorphopsia | Brad Duchaine
3/3/2024
In this special episode of Brain in a Vat, Brad Duchaine from the Psychological and Brain Sciences Department at Dartmouth discusses prosopometamorphopsia (PMO) – a condition where individuals see distorted faces.
The episode explores various manifestations of PMO, including seeing demonic features, dragons, or entirely different faces, and distinguishes it from prosopagnosia (face blindness). It delves into the neurological basis of PMO, touching upon structural and functional differences in the brains of those affected.
We discuss the significant impact PMO and prosopagnosia have on individuals' social interactions and quality of life, as well as potential management techniques such as using glasses or colored lights to reduce distortions.
00:00 Introduction and Guest Presentation
00:20 Exploring the Case of Face Distortion
03:19 Understanding the Nature of Distortions
05:49 Comparing Prosopagnosia and PMO
07:17 The Role of Visual System in Face Recognition
10:01 Impact of Face Recognition on Social Interactions
14:16 The Spectrum of Face Recognition Abilities
16:20 The Role of AI and Hallucinations in Face Recognition
23:48 Understanding the Diagnosis of Face Recognition Disorders
30:20 Understanding Prosopagnosia: Prevalence and Characteristics
31:59 The Mystery of PMO: Prevalence and Need for More Research
32:46 Exploring the Impact of Prosopagnosia and PMO on Social and Sexual Relationships
33:23 The Intersection of PMO and Other Psychiatric Conditions
37:03 The Struggles and Challenges of Living with Prosopagnosia and PMO
41:02 Potential Treatments and Coping Mechanisms for PMO
51:22 The Neurological Basis of PMO and Prosopagnosia
54:51 Testing and Characterizing PMO: A Deep Dive into Research Methods
59:54 Understanding the Perception and Processing of Faces in PMO
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:01:01:22
Pornography and Free Speech | Nadine Strossen and Holly Lawford-Smith
2/25/2024
We welcome back Nadine Strossen for a comprehensive discussion about pornography and free speech. She highlights points from her re-released book 'Defending Pornography', explaining why she supports the freedom of sexual expression. Her thought experiment is about a respected academic who makes adult videos, raising questions about personal freedom, professional reputability, and potential harm to his university. She also explores the complex relationship between pornography, liberty, and equality, emphasizing that context matters when considering whether freedom of speech overrides other concerns. The conversation also touches on whether pornography subordinates women, Nadine underlines that she defends the right to pornography not because she is an aficionado, but because she believes in individual choices. (00:00) Introduction and Guest Presentation(00:37) Understanding Pornography and Free Speech(02:00) Controversies Surrounding Pornography(02:12) Case Study: Provost's Scandal(03:22) Debate on the Provost's Case(03:54) Exploring the Concept of Academic Freedom(05:10) Counter Argument: The Question of Judgment(06:43) The Impact of Sexual Taboos(07:30) The Role of the American Association of University Professors(08:16) Discussion on the Provost's First Amendment Claim(12:12) The Shift in Pornography Production(17:58) The Debate on Virtual Child Pornography(27:14) The Feminist Perspective on Pornography(40:13) Understanding the Real Case of Subordination(40:29) The Role of Subordination in Fantasy and Pornography(41:05) The Radical Feminist Anti-Pornography Movement(41:56) Analyzing Media and Subordinating Imagery(42:45) The Impact of Subordinating Imagery(42:59) The Irony of Anti-Pornography Activism(43:58) The Controversy of Subordinating Images in Public Spaces(45:05) The Role of Pornography in Society(46:15) The Popularity and Impact of Pornography(47:31) The Positive Benefits of Pornography(48:30) Balancing Liberty and Equality in Free Speech(55:02) The Intersection of Hate Speech and Pornography(01:00:02) The Egalitarian Nature of Pornography(01:05:48) The Controversy of Being a 'Minority Intellectual Dissident' --- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:01:13:02
Unravelling “White Privilege” | Spencer Case
2/18/2024
Can the definition of privilege be nuanced enough to address the broad range of individual experiences and historical contexts? Does recognizing and discussing privilege lead to meaningful social change? Or does talk of privilege oversimplify complex issues?
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:01:00:29
The Privacy Paradox | David Boonin
2/11/2024
Is observing people in a public space from the privacy of your home an infringement of their rights? Can the widespread use of CCTV cameras be justified, or does it violate their privacy? And how do technological developments affect the delicate balance between safety and privacy?
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:01:00:35
Dissecting Morality: Error Theory | Matt Lutz
2/4/2024
What if our understanding of morality is fundamentally flawed? Should the absence of objective moral facts alter the way we live and interact? Is the structure of our society dependent on moral beliefs, or are these just a result of individual desires and social evolution?
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:01:01:49
The Morality Maze | Spencer Case
1/28/2024
Is morality real, a social construct, or non-existent? Can we rely on our moral intuitions? And are moral truths inaccessible to us?
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:00:58:06
Why Israel's Response to Hamas Was Justified | Natasha Hausdorff
1/21/2024
What is a proportional response to a terrorist attack? What does genocide involve? And is South Africa's case at the International Court of Justice justified? Presenters: Mark Oppenheimer and Jason Werbeloff Editor and Producer: Jimmy Mullen and Porter Kaufman Brain in a Vat bookshop (Shopify): https://smarturl.it/BrainShop Brain in a Vat bookshop (Amazon): https://smarturl.it/BrainAmazonShop
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:00:51:57
The Trouble with Gender | Alex Byrne
1/14/2024
Does the biology you were born with trump self-identity when determining your sex or gender? Is gender innate, or can it change? And what can real-life cases of children being reassigned their sex at birth teach us?
Alex's Book: https://www.amazon.com/Trouble-Gender-Sex-Facts-Fictions/dp/1509560017/
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:00:57:44
John Rawls: Justice as Fairness | Paul Weithman (Rebroadcast)
1/7/2024
John Rawls is widely regarded as the greatest modern liberal philosopher. Does his theory of justice lead to a fair society?
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:00:57:07
Near-Death Experiences | John Martin Fischer (Rebroadcast)
12/31/2023
Is there life after death? Are near-death experiences meaningful? Are they similar to other altered states like meditation and drug-induced hallucinations?
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:01:04:58
How To End Global Poverty | Andy Kuper (Rebroadcast)
12/24/2023
Andy Kuper, the founder and CEO of LeapFrog Investments, tells us how his PHD in philosophy led him to marry profit with purpose, by creating investment funds with deep impact on the lives of 200 million low-income people worldwide, while generating strong returns for its investors and the companies in which it invests.
https://leapfroginvest.com
Andy's Book Democracy Beyond Borders: https://www.amazon.com/Democracy-Beyond-Borders-Representation-Institutions-ebook-dp-B000WNHG48/dp/B000WNHG48/
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:00:56:43
Evolutionary Psychology | Justin Garson (Rebroadcast)
12/17/2023
Is evolution the root cause of racism, rape, and disgust? Are differences between men and women a result of both nature and nurture? Are some forms of scientific inquiry too dangerous to allow?
Justin's Book: https://www.amazon.com/Biological-Mind-Philosophical-Introduction/dp/0367466317
--- Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/braininavat/message
Duration:00:53:39